WordPress CEO Matt Mullenweg goes ‘nuclear’ on Silver Lake, WP Engine
Automattic founder, Matt Mullenweg
Supply: Automattic
Matt Mullenweg, who turned 40 in January, has now spent greater than half his life engaged on WordPress. He is by no means had such an insane two weeks.
WordPress, greatest often called a number one content material administration system, has hundreds of millions of sites at present utilizing its templates, instruments and plugins. However the WordPress universe is an advanced mishmash of open-source merchandise, nonprofits, for-profit firms, logos and licenses.
The usually quiet however extraordinarily vital a part of the web — WordPress powers roughly 40% of all web sites — has all of a sudden emerged as a significant supply of tech business drama, threatening to upend an ecosystem that is lengthy been considered, from the surface at the least, as collegial, due to its longevity and the assorted fun-loving camps and studying periods it hosts yearly.
Whereas WordPress’ know-how is open supply, which means anybody can set up it and use it without spending a dime, Mullenweg can be founder and CEO of Automattic, a venture-backed startup valued at $7.5 billion, as of 2021. WordPress.com is Automattic’s central companies, and people and corporations pay wherever from $4 a month to over $25,000 a 12 months for companies like advert merchandise, safety, buyer help and stock administration.
The saga that burst into public view in September featured the usually mild-mannered Mullenweg as its central character in a battle with WP Engine, one of many main suppliers of WordPress internet hosting. Silicon Valley personal fairness agency Silver Lake purchased a majority stake in WP Engine in 2018, investing $250 million and acquiring three board seats.
“I have been doing WordPress for 21 years, I’ve good relationships with each different firm on this planet,” Mullenweg mentioned in an interview this week with CNBC.
WP Engine’s offense, in response to Mullenweg and a cease-and-desist letter his attorneys despatched to the corporate on Sept. 23, revolves round years of trademark violations and WP Engine’s declare that it is bringing “WordPress to the plenty.”
“We at Automattic have been trying to make a licensing cope with them for a really very long time, and all they’ve accomplished is string us alongside,” Mullenweg wrote in a Sept. 26 post on his private web site, ma.tt. “Lastly, I drew a line within the sand, which they’ve now leapt over.”
Since then, the matter has escalated on an virtually each day foundation. WordPress took the drastic step of banning WP Engine from utilizing the WordPress sources essential to serve its prospects, which preceded a lawsuit filed on Wednesday by WP Engine in opposition to Mullenweg and Automattic. Within the swimsuit, the corporate mentioned it had not violated trademark legislation and that Mullenweg was utilizing it for anticompetitive practices.
Mullenweg then put out one other submit, calling WP Engine’s swimsuit “meritless,” and asserting that he’d employed Neal Katyal, former U.S. appearing solicitor normal, for authorized protection.
Tomasz Tunguz, a enterprise capitalist and founding father of Theory Ventures, says the battle speaks to the perpetual problem of open-source software program.
“What are the reputable methods of monetizing open supply and does the business entity created by the authors — how a lot management ought to they’ve with the commercialization efforts?” Tunguz mentioned. On this case, “a whole lot of hundreds of thousands in income is at stake between the 2,” he added.
‘Silver Lake does not give a dang’
In Mullenweg’s telling of the brouhaha, the battle has been years within the making. He is been actively making an attempt to strike a deal since January and at last bought fed up, he mentioned.
However to the surface world, all of it felt very sudden. Mullenweg first referenced the matter in public on Sept. 17, in a blog post forward of WordCamp, the most important annual gathering within the U.S. of WordPress customers. The four-day occasion occurred in Portland, Oregon, starting on Sept. 17.
Within the submit, Mullenweg criticized WP Engine for not contributing sufficient again to the WordPress ecosystem. He mentioned that Automattic contributed 3,786 hours per week to WordPress.org, (“not even counting me!”) in comparison with 47 hours for WP Engine.
WP Engine says in its lawsuit that these numbers are incorrect and that its contributions again to WordPress have been far increased, together with via occasions, convention sponsorships and creating academic sources.
For companies and builders contemplating who they need to help, Mullenweg had this message: “Silver Lake does not give a dang about your Open Supply beliefs. It simply needs a return on capital.”
A Silver Lake spokesperson mentioned WP Engine was dealing with all inquiries. A WP Engine consultant referred to the corporate’s grievance in opposition to Automattic and Mullenweg, filed on Oct. 2. The spokesperson highlighted the introduction of the grievance.
“It is a case about abuse of energy, extortion, and greed,” the submitting begins. “The misconduct at difficulty right here is all of the extra stunning as a result of it occurred in an sudden place — the WordPress open supply software program group constructed on guarantees of the liberty to construct, run, change, and redistribute with out boundaries or constraints, for all. These guarantees weren’t stored, and that group was betrayed, by the wrongful acts of some—[Matt Mullenweg and Automattic]—to the detriment of the numerous, together with WPE.”
WP Engine additionally says within the grievance that the primary calls for from Automattic for giant sums of cash got here within the days main as much as the convention. The corporate says these calls for have been accompanied by baseless claims and threats towards WP Engine.
In a follow-up assertion to CNBC, a WP Engine spokesperson mentioned Mullenweg’s antics had “harmed not simply our firm, however your entire WordPress ecosystem.” The spokesperson added that Mullenweg’s “conduct during the last ten days has uncovered important conflicts of curiosity and governance points that, if left unchecked, threaten to destroy” the belief of the WordPress group.
On Sept. 20, three days after Mullenweg’s preliminary submit, the WordPress founder confirmed he would not be backing down.
In his keynote, at an occasion that attracted an estimated 1,500 WordPress fanatics, Mullenweg warned the viewers upfront that it “may be one in every of my spiciest WordCamp displays ever.” After studying out his prior weblog submit, Mullenweg took swipes at Silver Lake, even naming a companion on the agency, Lee Wittlinger, as the person behind WP Engine, evaluating him to a “schoolyard bully.”
Previous to taking questions, Mullenweg mentioned of WP Engine’s presence at WordCamp, “they don’t seem to be going to be at future ones, I do not assume.”
He wasn’t accomplished.
The subsequent day, in a submit titled, “WP Engine shouldn’t be WordPress,” Mullenweg wrote that even his mom did not know the distinction, and he mentioned WP Engine is “profiting off of the confusion” and “wants a trademark license to proceed their enterprise.”
His mother wasn’t the one one confused.
Bob Perkowitz, president of environmental nonprofit ecoAmerica, instructed CNBC that he is identified Mullenweg for 16 years and is even an investor in Automattic. For various his organizational and private web sites, Perkowitz mentioned he is lengthy been a WP Engine buyer. Tuning in remotely, he heard Mullenweg’s WordCamp presentation.
“I all the time thought that was a part of WordPress,” Perkowitz instructed CNBC in an interview, referring to WP Engine. “They’re deceptive, and so they do not contribute to the group.”
Perkowitz mentioned he is having his web site administrator migrate all the web sites to completely different internet hosting firms.
Quickly after Mullenweg’s presentation, WP Engine despatched Automattic’s authorized chief a cease-and-desist letter on Sept. 23, because of what the corporate known as Mullenweg’s self-described “scorched earth nuclear strategy” and a smear marketing campaign in opposition to WP Engine. The letter mentioned Mullenweg had demanded a payout of a “very massive sum of cash” earlier than his WordCamp keynote, and WP Engine did not pay up.
The letter mentioned Mullenweg’s “false, deceptive, and disparaging statements are legally actionable.”
Two days later, Mullenweg wrote on the WordPress.org site that WP Engine had been banned, which means it “now not has free entry to WordPress.org’s sources.” Mullenweg inspired WP Engine’s hundreds of shoppers to contact the corporate “and ask them to repair it.”
WordPress then quickly unblocked WP Engine and gave it till Oct. 1 to conform to phrases of a licensing settlement, which Mullenweg made public. The crux of the deal is that WP Engine would conform to a royalty payment of 8% of month-to-month income to Automattic or commit 8% of income “within the type of salaries of WP Engine staff” engaged on WordPress options for WordPress.org.
No deal was made. The ban went into impact Oct. 1.
To the universe of WP Engine prospects, Mullenweg’s actions have been harsh and clumsy. Mullenweg says that what his critics do not perceive is how lengthy he is been making an attempt to come back to a deal.
“They have been delaying eternally,” Mullenweg instructed CNBC. He determined, “I’ll lastly begin speaking in regards to the evil stuff you are doing except you discuss to me,” he mentioned.
Combating again
Removed from negotiating, WP Engine on Wednesday filed its explosive lawsuit in opposition to Mullenweg and Automattic.
WP Engine accuses Mullenweg of slander and libel because of his public feedback and says the WordPress founder has quite a few conflicts of curiosity in how he runs the group and his firm, given the open-source nature of the know-how.
“During the last two weeks, Defendants have been finishing up a scheme to ban WPE from the WordPress group except it agreed to pay tens of hundreds of thousands of {dollars} to Automattic for a purported trademark license that WPE doesn’t even want,” the lawsuit says. “Defendants’ plan, which got here with out warning, gave WPE lower than 48 hours to both conform to pay them off or face the results of being banned and publicly smeared.”
Following WP Engine’s calls for for a jury trial in its 61-page lawsuit, Mullenweg fired again, describing the grievance as “baseless” and “flawed, begin to end.”
On his private web site, Mullenweg acknowledged that the ordeal was inflicting a giant inner conflict at his firm.
“It turned clear an excellent chunk of my Automattic colleagues disagreed with me and our actions,” Mullenweg wrote.
He says he made the choice to supply buyout packages for anybody who resigned earlier than early afternoon Thursday, providing $30,000 or six months of wage, whichever is increased. Anybody who took the deal would not be eligible to “boomerang,” a time period for getting rehired.
Mullenweg mentioned that 159 folks, or 8.4% of the workforce, took the supply whereas the 91.6% who opted to remain turned down a collective $126 million.
Mullenweg concluded by saying, “now I really feel a lot lighter.”
“I am grateful and grateful for all of the individuals who took the supply, and much more excited to work with those that turned down $126M to remain,” Mullenweg wrote. “As the children say, LFG!”
Mullenweg could also be brazenly enthusiastic and grateful for the staff he nonetheless has on board, however the WordPress group is a large number. Many WP Engine prospects are struggling, and Automattic is gearing up for a authorized combat in opposition to a personal fairness agency with over $100 billion in property.
WATCH: An open-source future
