Realtor.com CEO: CoStar Made “Misleading And Deceptive” Claims
At Inman Connect Las Vegas, July 30-Aug. 1, 2024, the noise and misinformation shall be banished, all of your huge questions shall be answered, and new enterprise alternatives shall be revealed. Join us.
Realtor.com has been round for years, however recently, it has been round much more.
That’s as a result of the corporate is likely one of the fundamental gamers in what is typically referred to as the portal wars. It’s a wrestle between the principle consumer-facing residence search platforms for supremacy. Realtor.com is the oldest of the foremost gamers, and for a few years comfortably held the second place spot after rival Zillow.
Extra not too long ago, nonetheless, CoStar has been aggressively pushing into the area with its Properties.com model, and that push has helped make the competitors between the businesses one of many greatest actual property tales of the 2020s.
The portal wars have included many verbal barbs at commerce occasions, and extra not too long ago, lawsuits and complaints to the Higher Enterprise Bureau. However the finish result’s that with regards to Realtor.com, regardless of its lengthy historical past, it has arguably by no means been within the information extra.
All the eye has additionally put Damian Eales — CEO of Realtor.com mum or dad Transfer, Inc. — below the microscope, and since taking the reins at the company in 2023 he has turn into one of many trade’s most seen leaders. Eales will make an look on the upcoming Inman Connect Las Vegas this month, and in anticipation of that occasion we caught up with him to speak concerning the portal wars, the market, commission lawsuits and extra.
The takeaway from this dialog is that Eales believes his firm has a novel place available in the market, gives increased high quality results in brokers than different portals, and is actively engaged on new development alternatives. Eales can be lower than impressed with Realtor.com’s chief rival — and had some pointed phrases concerning the ongoing competitors.
What follows is a model of that dialog that has been edited for size and readability.
Inman: The Nationwide Promoting Division [of the Better Business Bureau] on Tuesday recommended that your rival Costar cease making some distinctive customer claims, together with about their relationship to you. It feels like Realtor.com was behind the grievance, so discuss to me about why you made it and what your response to this discovering was.
Damian Eales: We had been behind the grievance. It was CoStar making misleading and deceptive claims in opposition to Realtor.com that had been inaccurate. And people claims trigger prospects available in the market, Realtors, to half with cash on false pretenses. We don’t assume that’s proper.
CoStar has been calling out an viewers of 156 million for Properties.com. That’s how their advert learn. And what they had been doing in that was aggregating 17 URLs. So far as we perceive, until they will exhibit in any other case, each a type of URLs is being calculated independently on Google Analytics, after which they’re aggregating that viewers. It’s evaluating apples with oranges. We expect that’s misleading and deceptive.
We’ll proceed to generate a high-quality viewers that generates high-quality leads for each shopping for brokers and itemizing brokers, and we’ll let CoStar win within the competitors for exaggeration.
Every other response to the Nationwide Promoting Division’s censure of CoStar?
I haven’t actually gone on the market and mentioned this as of but, so I’ll give it to you, however I believe that their campaign, fairly frankly, has been considerably of a flop. In case you have a look at their Tremendous Bowl marketing campaign, on any impartial measure of viewers, they haven’t achieved the target that they’ve claimed to the trade and to the market.
In September of final 12 months, on essentially the most beneficiant impartial measure of their viewers, they hit an viewers of 48 million in September. Regardless of the extraordinary cash that they’re spending on [their ongoing advertising campaign], their viewers [then] hit 40 million. Within the months intervening, it was within the 20s and 30 million.
In different phrases, regardless of that Tremendous Bowl funding, they didn’t exceed their earlier peak.
So on that foundation, in the event that they peaked in final September, they achieved much less with the Tremendous Bowl, and so they’ve gone backwards since then. Regardless of that extraordinary funding, the marketing campaign has failed.
Why do you assume that may very well be?
I don’t assume shoppers who view their advertisements actually perceive what they’re attempting to say. And I believe that they’ve purchased an entire lot of very cheap, low-cost clicks to their website. And low-cost clicks don’t convert right into a extremely engaged viewers, nor do they convert into high quality leads for his or her prospects. I do know Realtors rather well, and I do know full nicely that the factor that irks them most is poor-quality leads.
At Realtor.com we’re very centered on producing a high-intent, extremely engaged viewers that’s going to generate high-quality leads.
Let me ask you about leads, as a result of one in all our reporters just talked to CoStar CEO Andy Florence, and he mentioned Information Corp, your mum or dad firm, is stealing leads and that what you are promoting mannequin is unpopular. How do you reply to that?
I believe it’s preposterous, and the rationale it’s preposterous is as a result of People sometimes select to make use of a purchaser agent, and those that use a purchaser agent sometimes need to use the identical purchaser agent in 90 % of events for his or her subsequent transaction.
One of many nice issues concerning the American system is that purchaser company exists. The idea of impartial purchaser company has been an amazing win for client advocates on this market. And we predict that advocating and supporting purchaser brokers to shoppers and to lawmakers is a really applicable consequence for our firm. Our prospects recognize it as a result of they perceive the worth of impartial purchaser company.
The opposite factor I might say is that I believe CoStar tries to place us as if we solely service the client facet of the market. That’s fully false. We additionally service itemizing brokers. We have now two vital merchandise. A serious development part of our income is servicing itemizing brokers by offering them with our itemizing agent toolkit, and servicing homesellers by providing them Actual Selection Promoting, which gives them a alternative of itemizing brokers.
Realtor.com’s mum or dad firm just filed a lawsuit over data theft. CoStar has come out and referred to as it a PR stunt, and so they’ve characterised the worker on the middle of the case as a low-level man. Is their characterization correct?
Properly, clearly we don’t assume their characterization is correct. Past that, I’m not going to remark any additional. I’ll say that we don’t take doing this calmly. We’ve solely had one comparable case of this nature within the final decade. That’s fairly telling. We have now monumental respect for the judicial course of and we are going to litigate within the courts, not within the media, which is how CoStar has chosen to behave.
Let’s pivot to the antitrust commission lawsuits. What sort of fallout may we see from these circumstances?
I’ve mentioned beforehand that it’s clear that the [Biden] administration needs to place downward strain on the price of housing. And a part of the price of housing is the price of the transaction. I do imagine that the actions which have been taken — each by way of the DOJ’s affect and by way of the NAR settlement — might put downward strain on commissions.
I additionally assume that there are some advantages which will circulate from this by way of a extra skilled trade. , I don’t assume the idea of assigning a purchaser company settlement is a nasty factor. I believe it offers a extremely good alternative for a purchaser agent to exhibit the professionalism of their position.
It’ll most likely end in fewer Realtors as a result of it requires a extra skilled stage of service. That’s an excellent factor for the trade.
However I’ve by no means heard from the DOJ or from the antitrust attorneys is any assertion to the impact of, we would like decrease commissions on the expense of eliminating client protections, and particularly purchaser company. Nobody mentioned that. And so I imagine that frequent sense will prevail.
What’s your take in the marketplace?
We’re cautiously optimistic. We don’t assume that rates of interest are going to fall dramatically or in a rush, however clearly we see them coming down over time. And we count on that residence gross sales will get better on account of that.
Equally, there are much less and fewer folks available in the market with a 30-year mortgage below 4 %. And so to some extent, a brand new regular is turning into regular. Because of that, we count on that life goes on, and transactions inevitably will happen.
Do you see any reduction on the affordability entrance within the close to future?
We’ve forecasted modest development over the subsequent 12 months in residence costs. However it actually relies upon. Loads will depend upon provide. So clearly, relying on the extent to which the rates of interest fall, the extent to which the market opens up, the extent to which new stock comes in the marketplace, after which the extent to which individuals are able to transact. However I believe that from our perspective, we’ve solely estimated modest development in residence costs.
Tease for me your Join look. What do trade members have to know proper now? What message do you need to share with them?
I’m actually eager to speak about Realtor.com’s technique. I believe we’ve got a completely distinctive place within the market. And that place is that having been born of the trade, we’ve got a really deep reference to each MLSs and with our prospects. We’re not right here to disintermediate them. We’re not right here to turn into the nationwide MLS. We’re right here to seek out methods to assist them to make sure that their enterprise grows. I believe that that separates us from our main rivals.
One of many ways in which we do that’s by means of constructing a top quality viewers. And we’re doing loads of work in loads of completely different ways in which I can discuss on stage. Issues like leveraging the Information Corp community, which has been unbelievable during the last 12 months. Subsequent 12 months, you’re going to see much more integration with the Fox community, which we’ll be capable to discuss.
As well as, we’re using loads of know-how. As I mentioned to you earlier than, the very last thing that our prospects need is dangerous leads, and we all know that with a few of our rivals, they get loads of these dangerous leads. So we’re doing loads of work to put money into know-how to make sure that leads are nurtured. That the standard is enhanced such that the conversion price for these leads goes up.
We’ll additionally need to discuss concerning the work that we’re doing to assist the trade, which positions us fully otherwise to some other portal. No one else is doing it like Realtor.com is doing it.
Additionally, we’ve got different technique of unlocking development. As a lot as we’re very centered on the core purchase and promote a part of our enterprise, we’ve got additionally invested loads of time and power into our new rentals partnership with Zillow. It’s necessary to notice that our viewers plus Zillow’s viewers is now exceeds Residences.com’s viewers.
From a brand new houses perspective, our new houses enterprise has grown very considerably within the final 12 months. Immediately, our partnership with the constructing trade is second to none.
So we will discuss extra about all of this on stage.
Be part of us to see Damian Eales reside at Inman Connect Las Vegas, July 30-Aug. 1 on the Aria Resort and On line casino. Reserve your spot now to achieve entry to actual property’s premier occasion.
