Andy Florance Calls Realtor.com Lawsuit “PR Stunt,” Talks Future
At Inman Connect Las Vegas, July 30-Aug. 1, 2024, the noise and misinformation might be banished, all of your large questions might be answered, and new enterprise alternatives might be revealed. Join us.
CoStar CEO Andy Florance punched again at authorized claims made by certainly one of its fiercest rivals this week, saying he has a superior enterprise mannequin that has already surpassed opponents in significant metrics.
Florance mentioned he was glad to be within the ring with Transfer, Inc., CEO Damian Eales, whom Florance referred to as a “boxer” main a crew whose newest punch was a newly filed lawsuit. Transfer, which owns Realtor.com, filed go well with in California final week accusing a CoStar worker, who beforehand labored for Realtor.com, of stealing commerce secrets and techniques to achieve an unfair benefit for CoStar’s Houses.com.
The lawsuit got here amid an ongoing battle between the nation’s 4 largest actual property portals — Zillow, Houses.com, Realtor.com and Redfin — for the biggest viewers of shoppers shopping listings and actual property professionals who pay the websites for varied providers.
Realtor.com accused a former senior editorial director at Realtor.com, of improperly accessing a key doc that helped information and inform site visitors to the web site for months after he was employed by Houses.com.
Florance minimized the worker’s position within the group, saying he “got here to work for us as an editor writing rental descriptions” after being laid off from Realtor.com early this yr.
“I referred to as 5 completely different individuals and couldn’t discover anyone who’d ever heard of the man,” Florence mentioned. “I’d by no means heard of the man.”
As an alternative, Florence mentioned Realtor.com was lashing out at its rival as a result of its enterprise mannequin was going through an “existential disaster.”
In response, a Realtor.com spokesperson mentioned the corporate would deal with the matter within the courts.
“We don’t take motion like this frivolously and have solely had one related case within the final decade,” the spokesperson mentioned. “We’re assured within the deserves of our motion, and out of respect for the judicial system, we are going to litigate within the courts, not the media.”
Inman spoke with Florance the day earlier than an arm of the Higher Enterprise Bureau recommended Homes.com stop using two key site visitors claims in its promoting on account of a problem filed by Transfer, Inc. The BBB mentioned the site visitors for Houses.com was 110 million month-to-month distinctive guests, fairly than the 156 million claimed in advertisements by Houses.com. Realtor.com’s site visitors, in the meantime, is 66 million, the group mentioned.
Florence make clear his serious about the battle for internet site visitors, the lawsuit and competing with Zillow forward of his appearance July 30-Aug. 1 at Inman Connect Las Vegas.
Under is a transcript of the interview, edited for readability and brevity.
Inman: Let’s give attention to the brand new lawsuit. It appears sensitive as a result of this worker, in keeping with them, was central in driving site visitors to Realtor.com after which had a aggressive benefit taking that over to CoStar due to the entry that he needed to the doc, in keeping with their lawsuit. And it simply appeared to me to maintain the give attention to that information — that the net site visitors to each Houses.com and to Realtor.com and the others — everybody appears sensitive about that. This was type of the most recent flip of that storyline.
Florance: Earlier than I reply the query, I’d say that Zillow just isn’t sensitive about it. They’re fairly laid-back. I’d say particularly Realtor’s sensitive about it. And by Realtor, I don’t imply the Nationwide Affiliation of Realtors. I imply Information Corp.
I’d say that they’ve acquired an existential disaster in that enterprise. They’d hoped to promote the enterprise final yr for $3 billion or so, and that hasn’t occurred for them. And it’s an existential disaster if they’re not one of many largest web sites the place individuals store for houses.
And it’s additionally an existential disaster if their enterprise mannequin turns into ineffective. And so the 2 issues which are being threatened there are actual. And that’s why you find yourself with issues like a PR-oriented lawsuit.
So site visitors is a giant part of this and has been since October when CoStar first introduced it surpassed Realtor.com in site visitors.
No one on this planet would have predicted that that may have occurred that rapidly. It’s just like the White Home when Sputnik launched or one thing.
In order that’s why you’re getting a whole lot of flack blowing up across the numbers. As a result of in any market, having an enormous viewers of potential house consumers is necessary. And the second main situation is we’re bringing Your Itemizing, Your Result in the market. I do know I am going on and on about it, however it’s actual and it’s necessary and it will be the long run. I don’t imagine that the enterprise mannequin that was right here once we arrived, the Zillow and Realtor lead diversion mannequin, is the long run.
Universally, Zillow’s lead diversion enterprise mannequin is wildly unpopular. Brokers universally hate it. Realtor[.com]’s traditionally gotten somewhat little bit of a go. They’ve the very same enterprise mannequin as Zillow, however they’ve gotten a go as a result of brokers don’t notice that the Nationwide Affiliation of Realtors bought off Realtor.com a very long time in the past, and it has no affiliation with NAR. Information Corp is stealing the leads. That’s why this lawsuit exists. One thing to attempt to change issues.
In order that’s why they filed this lawsuit?
It’s an entry-level worker and a crew of a thousand individuals producing content material. Our content material technique is obvious and well-known. That is ridiculous. If this worker had any information or entry to any information, he by no means gave it to anybody doing technique. By no means had contact with anybody doing technique. This man is a pawn in a PR stunt. It’s somewhat merciless.
You hearth the man, and you then sue the man for one thing that’s immaterial if something occurred. The man’s a author, proper? So what we’re doing is we’re writing narratives on condominium buildings. There’s a small crew of writers in New York.
In case you don’t thoughts me pushing again somewhat bit on that, Andy. This man’s resume is insane. He has a really prestigious pedigree from different journalistic shops. And once we look again on the site visitors part of issues, CoStar has a information crew that drives site visitors to CoStar and builds its model popularity. I presume he has strategic significance for CoStar. I assume, given that everybody else has that very same type of part — Realtor.com, Zillow — all of them have information groups. This man is a content material lead and it looks as if you may be diminishing his position, with all due respect.
There’s a man in Richmond who’s answerable for the content material weblog for the location. This man’s not that man. There’s a man in Richmond who that man experiences to. It’s not that man. And this man is employed as an individual enhancing rental narratives in New York. There’s nothing strategic about it.
There’s a proper to work in America. In case you’re an individual who has a job and your organization lays you off, and also you’re a author or an editor, you may have the fitting to go be a author or editor elsewhere. This man has the fitting to work.
The larger situation is that is clearly a frivolous lawsuit that’s an act of desperation as a result of they face an existential disaster as a result of they’ve acquired a foul enterprise mannequin. To credit score Zillow that had a lead diversion mannequin, while you hearken to Wealthy Barton speaking these days, he’s downplaying the lead diversion mannequin and he’s upplaying every thing else. Realtor[.com] hasn’t but found out they need to get away from that enterprise. And as a substitute, they’re throwing comparatively junior workers that they laid off underneath the truck.
You talked about Zillow. Presumably, they’re in your sights. You wish to surpass them. We’ve talked quite a bit about site visitors. They’ve been updating their enterprise mannequin. However you’re presumably coming for them now.
Effectively, you might need heard a rumor that I used to be aggressive.
Sure.
It’s not true. What we wish to do is we wish to construct the premier residential website the place individuals market properties on the market and other people discover properties on the market. And with a view to try this, you need to have a whole lot of site visitors. I’m extremely assured that we’ve reached a site visitors stage by which we are able to present a ton of worth.
Anecdotally, I can see already that for our members, we’re offering dramatically extra site visitors to their listings than these members get on Zillow proper now. All in all, our members are getting as much as 10 instances as a lot site visitors on their listings on our website as they get on Zillow.
So we’ve already beat Zillow to some extent as a result of our enterprise mannequin is completely different. They’re attempting to promote the brokers. We’re attempting to promote the properties. And, once we assist individuals promote properties, it helps them win listings. By enjoying on a distinct enjoying area like we’re doing with Your Itemizing, Your Lead, we’re already beating them on site visitors so far as our prospects are involved.
How does this site visitors dispute get resolved? You targeted on who’s making the noise right here and the way they’re making the noise. You’re a aggressive particular person. Presumably, you don’t like an organization that’s questioning your organization’s, and possibly thereby your, popularity in public. They’ve questioned your site visitors numbers, and now, they’re type of claiming commerce secret theft. How does this finish?
That is an entity that’s owned by Information Corp, and that’s the Murdoch household. In case you take a look at Information Corp, roughly 85 p.c of the worth of the corporate is the true property web sites. So for those who take the [New York] Submit and The Wall Road Journal and every thing else, all the opposite media operations they’ve, that’s solely 15 p.c of the market cap of Information Corp. So you’ll be able to think about having these web sites is fairly necessary to them. It’s many of the worth of the enterprise and you’d in all probability agree with me that the Murdochs will not be precisely shrinking violets in media.
While you go to compete with Information Corp, which is Realtor.com, which isn’t a part of NAR, they’re going to combat within the media. And that’s what they’re doing.
Once we actually began gaining traction, it pulled a man from Australia, Damian [Eales]. I believe they introduced him as a result of he’s a boxer, they usually’re going to throw every kind of punches. Frivolous lawsuits will lead to nothing. We simply made a alternative that we’re attempting to construct the most effective website. And if individuals wish to hurl private insults or if individuals wish to create faux information tales or lawsuits, that’s not going to cease us from delivering the most effective product attainable and profitable over the brokers one agent at a time with a greater product. So, yeah, I can take the warmth.
Trying forward
I do know the ink’s not dry. I do know it’s going by way of regulatory assessment. I don’t know what you’ll have the ability to share, however are you able to open up in any respect on what Matterport the acquisition means for CoStar? What are you going to make use of this factor for? What are you able to share?
I can simply say, basically, I actually imagine of their product. I’ve had the enjoyment of seeing some good expertise in my time. What we all know is {that a} high-quality, easy-to-build, 3D digital twin is one of the simplest ways to expertise actual property on-line. And it’s been underutilized in industrial actual property, in residential actual property.
We simply wish to go all in on that expertise, and we wish to make it ubiquitous on our platforms. We imagine it is going to draw extra site visitors. It’s one of the simplest ways to market a bit of actual property. And it has unbelievable, actual AI extensions. So already it’s the greatest instance of AI in actual property as a result of the way in which you construct the Matterport depends on an enormous studying mannequin and is AI-generated. Different merchandise use human labor to attempt to sew them collectively.
Is that this a Houses Professional providing? I understand how their income mannequin works. So presumably you’ll be able to’t shut it off and simply transfer all of it to CoStar, and also you’ve acquired to be a member to make use of Matterport, proper?
We wouldn’t try this. We’re going to offer it to anybody. All people. What we’re doing is Houses Professional members, we’ll simply Matterport their listings and generate ground plans. However anybody that desires to do Matterport, that’s unbelievable. We predict we win by jumpstarting demand, by placing Matterport up on houses.
I imagine homesellers are going to need that very same benefit with their advertising and marketing, and that can drive gross sales of Matterport outdoors of Houses Professional.
Be a part of us to see Andy Florance reside at Inman Connect Las Vegas, July 30-Aug. 1 on the Aria Resort and On line casino. Reserve your spot now to achieve entry to actual property’s premier occasion.
